Detained at Ben Gurion? The Rights of Non-Citizens at Border Control

Detained at Ben Gurion Airport during border control? Guide to the process, detention until departure, right to counsel, and judicial review procedures.

For Whom This Article Is Intended

It is important to clarify immediately: this article does **not** address routine security screening that Israeli citizens undergo when boarding a flight, nor does it address flight delays for operational reasons. The subject here is a different situation entirely — the detention and questioning of a **non-Israeli citizen** by border control (Border Control) of the Population and Immigration Authority upon landing at Ben Gurion Airport. Such a situation may result in denial of entry to Israel and return to the country of origin on the same or next flight.

This is a situation with serious legal and personal consequences: a person who arrived in Israel — sometimes after a long flight, with family members, for business, studies, or a visit — finds himself detained, questioned, and sometimes held in a confined area within the airport, without necessarily understanding his rights and the border control procedures that apply to him.

What Border Control Procedures at Ben Gurion Include

Under the Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952, anyone arriving in Israel must present themselves to a border control officer and present a valid passport or travel document. A border control officer is authorized, under Section 9 of the law, to "detain a person's entry pending investigation as to whether he is entitled to enter" — that is, to stop a passenger at the checkpoint and investigate his entitlement to enter Israel.

The investigation may include questions about the purpose of the visit, place of stay, connections in Israel, supporting documents, and more. If the border control officer concludes that the applicant for entry has no legal basis to enter Israel, the Minister of the Interior — and in practice the person authorized by him — may order the person's removal from the country, under Section 10(a) of the law.

Detention and Custody Until Departure from the Country

When a person is denied entry, a border control officer is authorized, under Section 10(b) of the Entry into Israel Law, to "hold such person at a place and manner as the Minister of the Interior has determined until his departure" from Israel. In practice, this means detention in a designated facility within the airport grounds until the passenger is placed on a return flight.

The definition of "detention" and "place of detention" under the law (Section 13(1)(a) (13א)) applies to this type of detention as well. The actual duration of detention depends on the availability of return flights and the circumstances of the case. As long as the detention continues and becomes detention of the type regulated in Part Four, Chapter B of the law, the mechanisms of judicial review described below apply to it.

The Right to Consult and Be Represented by Counsel

The Entry into Israel Law explicitly recognizes the possibility that a person held in detention may be represented — Section 13(20) (13כ) of the law provides that a person held in detention may be present at hearings concerning him and may also be represented — including, free of charge, by a representative who is not an attorney; representation by an attorney is possible under the general law applicable to administrative tribunals. The procedures of the Appeals Tribunal for detention review (regulated under the law) establish that in every hearing regarding a detainee, the tribunal first inquires whether he is represented, and if the detainee has stated he is represented but his counsel has not appeared — the tribunal may postpone the hearing to allow for the presence of the representative.

Beyond this specific arrangement, the general principle in Israeli law is that a person deprived of liberty is entitled to meet with counsel without undue delay, and an initial meeting with counsel should be made available even outside ordinary working hours of the detention facility. However, this principle was formulated explicitly in the context of criminal arrest (under the Criminal Procedure Law (Enforcement Powers - Arrests)), and its precise application to someone temporarily detained at Ben Gurion Airport pending a return flight is not entirely clear. In any case, as much as possible — it is recommended to attempt to make contact by telephone with counsel as soon as possible from the moment of detention.

Judicial Review: Detention Review Tribunal and Appeals Tribunal

The law provides two main channels of judicial review relevant to anyone detained at border control:

• **Detention Review Tribunal** — a judicial body operating under Part Four, Chapter B of the Entry into Israel Law. Its role is to conduct judicial review of decisions regarding the detention of a person, including regarding release on bail. Under Section 13(14) of the law, a detainee is brought before the tribunal, after a hearing, no later than 96 hours from the beginning of detention. Additionally, periodic review is established within 30 days. The tribunal's decision is subject to appeal, under Section 13(21)(a) of the law, to the Court for Administrative Matters. • **Appeals Tribunal** for matters of citizenship, entry, exit, stay and residence in Israel — established in 2014 under Amendment 22 to the Entry into Israel Law, and serves as the body for hearing appeals against decisions of the Population and Immigration Authority on these matters. Its decisions are subject to appeal, as of right, to the Courts for Administrative Matters.

In addition to these two channels, in urgent cases it is possible to concurrently consider a direct petition to the Court for Administrative Matters, including a request for an interim order that would stay the removal pending examination of the matter.

How Our Office Can Assist

Detention at border control at Ben Gurion Airport is a situation requiring quick navigation of the legal procedure, sometimes within hours. Our office represents individuals in situations of detention, questioning, or denial of entry at border control, and works, insofar as circumstances permit, to examine the options available to the client — both against border control itself, against the Appeals Tribunal for detention review, and in petitions to the relevant judicial bodies.

We clarify that there is no guarantee of any result — each case is examined according to its facts, available documents, and the time frame available to the applicant.

Experience of detention at border control at Ben Gurion has both serious legal and sensitive personal dimensions. If you or a family member has experienced detention, questioning, or notification of denial of entry at Ben Gurion Airport, you are welcome to contact us via WhatsApp or the contact form on the office website, to examine the circumstances and coordinate further handling.

What is the difference between routine security screening and detention by border control?

Routine security screening is generally conducted before boarding a flight and is not related to the question of the right to enter Israel. Detention by border control occurs upon landing in Israel, is conducted by a border control officer of the Population and Immigration Authority, and concerns the question of whether the arrivals have the right to enter Israel — and therefore may result in denial of entry.

How long can a person be held at Ben Gurion before being sent back?

The actual duration of waiting depends on the availability of flights and the specific circumstances of the case, and the law does not set a precise number of hours for such detention. As long as the detention continues and becomes detention of the type regulated in the law, there is an obligation to bring the matter before the Appeals Tribunal for detention review no later than 96 hours from the beginning of detention.

Am I allowed to ask to call counsel during detention?

The general principle in Israeli law is that a person deprived of liberty is entitled to contact and meet with counsel without undue delay. It is recommended to request this explicitly and as early as possible. In parallel, the Entry into Israel Law recognizes the right to representation of those held in detention by a "representative," including counsel.

Where do I turn if denial of entry has already been executed and I am no longer in Israel?

Even after removal from the country, depending on circumstances, it is possible, in accordance with the circumstances, to consider petitioning the relevant bodies in Israel or filing a new application for entry in the future. It is recommended to retain copies of all documents provided during detention (such as a written decision, if provided) and to seek legal advice to examine the specific options available to you.

Can I appeal the border control officer's decision?

There are channels for judicial review and appeal, including the Appeals Tribunal for detention review (regarding detention) and the Appeals Tribunal for matters of citizenship, entry and stay (regarding substantive decisions of the Population and Immigration Authority), from which you can appeal further to the Courts for Administrative Matters. The short time frame requires swift action.

Legal Articles | Idan Moldavski Law Office